Best Coffee Shops in the Hamptons
There’s nothing like starting your Hamptons morning with a perfectly brewed cup of coffee. Whether you’re looking for a quick espresso before heading to the beach or a cozy café to linger in, the Hamptons has some of the best coffee spots on Long Island.
From artisanal roasters to beachfront cafés, here’s where to find the best coffee in the Hamptons.
1. Sagtown Coffee (Sag Harbor)
A local favorite, Sagtown Coffee is known for its cozy vibe and expertly crafted espresso drinks. With outdoor seating and a selection of organic pastries, it’s the perfect place to start your day before exploring Sag Harbor’s charming streets.
📍 Location: 78 Main St, Sag Harbor
⭐ Try This: Oat Milk Latte + Avocado Toast
2. Hampton Coffee Company (Multiple Locations)
One of the original craft coffee roasters in the Hamptons, Hampton Coffee Company serves up locally roasted blends in a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Whether you visit their Southampton, Water Mill, Montauk, or Westhampton Beach locations, you’ll find fantastic brews and homemade treats.
📍 Locations: Southampton, Water Mill, Montauk, Westhampton Beach
⭐ Try This: Cold Brew + Blueberry Muffin
Check out Hampton Coffee Company
3. Grindstone Coffee & Donuts (Sag Harbor)
If you love handcrafted espresso and freshly made donuts, Grindstone is a must-visit. Their small-batch roasted coffee pairs perfectly with their famous maple bacon or classic glazed donuts.
📍 Location: 7A Main St, Sag Harbor
⭐ Try This: Flat White + Cinnamon Sugar Donut
4. Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee (Amagansett, Sag Harbor)
For those who prefer organic, ethically sourced coffee, Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee is the go-to spot. Their signature Stir Brew method creates a smooth, rich taste, and their baked goods are 100% vegan.
📍 Locations: Amagansett, Sag Harbor
⭐ Try This: Stir Brew Coffee + Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
5. Left Hand Coffee (Montauk)
Located near Montauk’s beaches, Left Hand Coffee is the ultimate stop for beachside coffee lovers. They specialize in organic, single-origin coffee with sustainable practices, making each sip feel good inside and out.
📍 Location: 83 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk
⭐ Try This: Nitro Cold Brew + Vegan Banana Bread
Stay Near the Best Coffee in the Hamptons
Start your Hamptons mornings right and book your stay at Hamptons Vacation Inn!
Prime Location: Just minutes from the best coffee shops and beaches
Pet-Friendly Stays: We welcome pets in designated pet-friendly rooms, including all Private Cottages (a pet fee applies)
Seasonal Getaway: We’re open May 22 to October 25, making us the perfect summer stay
Book now for Summer 2025! Call (631) 594-5740 or visit HamptonsVacationInn.com to reserve your stay!
Start Your Day with the Best Coffee in the Hamptons
The Hamptons is home to some of the best coffee spots on Long Island, perfect for every kind of coffee lover. Whether you’re craving an artisanal pour-over, a creamy latte, or an oceanfront cold brew, you’ll find the perfect cup here.
Ready to explore the Hamptons? Book your stay at Hamptons Vacation Inn and wake up to the best coffee & beachside mornings!