Best Must-Try Lobster Rolls in the Hamptons & North Fork

East End summers aren't complete without a lobster roll in hand—and whether you're into buttered or mayo-based, these iconic spots are serving up crustacean perfection from Montauk to Mattituck.

1. Clam Bar at Napeague – Amagansett

A classic roadside shack with unbeatable views and fresh lobster rolls that scream summer. clambarhamptons.com

2. Lobster Roll aka "Lunch" – Amagansett

The spot that made lobster rolls famous in the Hamptons. A must-visit for the vibe and the roll. lobsterroll.com

3. Canal Café – Hampton Bays

Right on the Shinnecock Canal, this hidden gem serves one of the best lobster rolls on Long Island—perfect after a beach day. canalcafe.com

4. Duryea’s Lobster Deck – Montauk

Upscale Montauk dining with killer harbor views and a seriously iconic lobster roll. duryealobsters.com

5. The Dock House – Sag Harbor

This wharfside staple is perfect for a grab-and-go lobster roll after strolling Main Street. dockhouseny.com

6. Southold Fish Market – Southold

Fresh, unfussy, and full of flavor—this North Fork gem is a go-to for seafood lovers. facebook.com/southoldfishmarket

7. The Fish Farm – Amagansett

No-frills, hyper-fresh, and totally local. Grab your lobster roll with a side of salty air. (No website—pull up for the full East End experience.)

8. Claudio’s – Greenport

Historic and bustling, Claudio’s serves up New England-style rolls with a Greenport twist. claudios.com

9. Love Lane Kitchen – Mattituck

Cozy café vibes with a surprisingly standout lobster roll. Worth the drive. lovelanekitchen.com

📍 From roadside classics to harborfront gems, these lobster roll spots are just a short drive from Hamptons Vacation Inn—your home base for exploring the East End.

We’re open seasonally from May 22 to October 25 and are located in beautiful Hampton Bays. We welcome pets in our designated pet-friendly rooms, including all of our Private Cottages (a pet fee applies).

Book your summer stay now at hamptonsvacationinn.com or call (631) 594-5740 to reserve your cottage by the coast.